Light cabinets or dark cabinets- what a conundrum! No element in your kitchen has as much of an impact as the cabinets.
The cabinetry —and the color you choose for them —can affect everything from the atmosphere of the room to the resale value of your home. As such, it’s crucial to take your time to consider all of the cabinet colors available to you.
One of the first and most important decisions you’ll need to make is whether you prefer light or dark kitchen cabinets. Read on below to help make your decision easier.
Light vs Dark Cabinets- Things to Consider
Cabinet color is one of the most strategic design elements in your kitchen, so it’s essential to decide whether light or dark cabinets will create the look you’re dreaming of.
Light cabinets enhance the room’s airiness, which can help your kitchen space feel bright and welcoming. This can be especially important in a smaller kitchen or one that lacks natural light. They are a classic choice for traditional kitchens and can improve the home’s resale value.
If you’re more interested in creating a rich atmosphere, dark cabinets add a luxurious feel. In recent years, dark shades have been closely associated with modernist kitchens, especially with streamlined hardware and high-quality countertops. However, choosing dark cabinets is a bold decision that may turn off potential buyers.
Careful planning is crucial before deciding on a light or dark cabinet finish, as it will significantly impact the overall ambiance. Evaluate your current layout, lighting sources, and overall kitchen design preferences before making your final decision.
Advantages of Light Kitchen Cabinets
Light kitchen cabinets create an inviting atmosphere, but they offer more than just a pleasing appearance. Factor in these key considerations to decide whether this classic look will brighten your kitchen space.
They Brighten and Enlarge the Space
Because light-colored cabinets reflect both natural and artificial light, they enlarge the visual space and create a more open atmosphere. This is essential for dimly lit or small spaces that might feel too cramped by dark colors.
They Work With Almost Any Color Scheme
Light cabinets create a neutral backdrop for other elements of your kitchen design, including your countertops, flooring, and backsplashes. They play nicely with vivid colors, ensuring visual interest without overwhelming guests.
Light Cabinets Are Always in Style
Your new kitchen is an investment, so you want to ensure it doesn’t become dated as kitchen trends change. Thankfully, light cabinetry has a timeless appeal that works well in both traditional and modern designs. You can be sure your kitchen will look fresh for decades to come.
They Can Boost Resale Value
Though you want your home to reflect your unique style, you also want to ensure you can sell it when that time comes. Because light cabinets are so versatile, buyers don’t need to worry about completely revamping the kitchen to match their own tastes. Additionally, light surfaces photograph better for listings and will command higher offers.
Advantages of Dark Kitchen Cabinets
Dark cabinetry is a statement piece, adding depth and intensity to your home. Consider these elements if you’re curious about how dark finishes could impact the feel of your space.
They Add Drama and Sophistication
Far from just functional furniture, dark kitchen cabinets demand attention and add visual weight. This luxurious, high-end look elevates your overall design, especially when boldly contrasted with lighter elements like stainless steel appliances and light walls.
They’re Great for Larger Spaces
While light cabinets visually expand a room, dark ones help large or open kitchens feel more intimate and balanced. This is ideal for a kitchen with more light, as it grounds the room and avoids eye strain.
They Hide Wear and Tear Better
While many love light kitchen cabinets for their pristine appearance, this look requires significant upkeep. Dark cabinets are more forgiving of everyday accidents, like scuffs, stains, and minor damage. They also require less frequent cleaning.
They Offer Bold Design Possibilities
Light-colored cabinets serve as a neutral backdrop for your design choices. In contrast, dark cabinetry offers opportunities for striking, dramatic combinations. For example, pair them with gold hardware and marble countertops for a cohesive look that commands respect, or use moody lighting to boost the room’s intensity.
The helpful team at iCabinetry Direct can help you choose between light and dark cabinets depending on your specific needs, ensuring you get the perfect fit for your space.
What’s Trending in Cabinet Colors Right Now?
Trendy kitchen cabinet designs appeal to both those who want light, airy spaces and those who want dramatic darkness. Consider these exciting color options for either side of the color spectrum.
- Light Kitchen Cabinets: Soft greige is a highly sought-after neutral that can be used in almost any design. Accent with black hardware or brushed nickel. Another popular option is taupe, which pairs well with brushed brass or aged pewter.
- Dark Kitchen Cabinets: Deep navy provides military precision to your kitchen, which looks fantastic with oiled-rubbed bronze or aged brass. You could also consider matte black with silver hardware, which contrasts dramatically with lighter countertops.
Two-Tone Cabinet Ideas: Best of Both Worlds
If you’re struggling between choosing dark cabinets and light ones, consider the two-tone cabinetry trend. This allows you to create exciting contrasts between different areas of the room. For example, you might have dark kitchen cabinets for the island, then light ones for the perimeter cabinets. This draws attention to the center of the room, anchoring the visual space.
Another great option is dark base cabinets with light upper cabinets. Not only will this ground the space, but it will also create the illusion of a taller ceiling and add more depth to the room.
Factors That May Affect Your Choice
Your cabinetry decision depends on much more than just looks. If you have kids or pets and don’t have time to clean every day, then dark cabinets may be a more prudent choice. Smaller rooms often do better with light cabinets. If you have abundant natural light, you can choose darker tones. Lastly, if you’re planning on moving soon, you may want to purchase light cabinets, as buyers prefer them.
How Lighting Impacts Cabinet Color Perception
Natural or artificial lighting can significantly change how a cabinet looks, accentuating or downplaying its undertone. As such, you should use paint samples or door samples to see how your cabinets will look in the room. Be sure to observe them during different lighting conditions, such as an overcast day or at night, to decide whether that color scheme looks good.
Light vs Dark Cabinets for Small Kitchens
While many homeowners choose light-colored cabinets because they create the illusion of more space, this doesn’t mean dark-colored cabinets are off the table based on room size. Dark kitchen cabinets shrink the perceived size of a kitchen, creating a cozier atmosphere when paired with ample lighting sources.
Consider natural wood cabinets with a dark stain to add a rustic warmth. You can then use a contrasting color, like lighter countertops, to create your desired ambiance.
Light vs Dark Cabinets for Open Floor Plans
Cabinetry choices are especially crucial for open-concept layouts. Light cabinets may work well if you want to create a seamless flow between rooms, such as matching cabinetry in the kitchen and dining room. On the other hand, dark cabinets will visually anchor the space to differentiate the kitchen from other areas. You also want to ensure you have adequate contrast between the flooring and the cabinets.
Interior Designer Tips for Making the Right Choice
- Test Cabinet Samples: You can order samples and test how they look at different times of day to determine whether they’re the right fit.
- Use Mood Boards: Our inspiration gallery is an excellent way to start thinking about how your cabinets will look in real life.
- Mixing Materials: Using different materials, like natural wood and marble, can add further depth and visual appeal.
- Consider Long-Term Value: Think about how your life might change in the future and ensure you accommodate this in your selections.
Our Expert Verdict: When to Go Light vs When to Go Dark
| Light Cabinets | Dark Cabinets | |
| Kitchen Size | Small kitchens | Large kitchens |
| Layout | Galley, U-shaped | Open-concept |
| Mood | Light, airy | Luxurious, warm |
| Kitchen Direction | North, East | South, West |
| Natural Lighting | Low or cool | Bright or warm |
| Kitchen Style | Traditional or transitional | Transitional or modern |
| Resale Potential | Good for resale | May deter potential buyers |
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Cabinet Color for Your Kitchen
There is no one right answer for which cabinets will work best for you, so it’s essential to balance your visual preferences with your lifestyle and resale goals. If you’re struggling to choose the perfect cabinets, iCabinetry Direct provides expert support about the potential drawbacks and benefits of different selections. Contact us today for a personalized quote and comprehensive service.
FAQs About Light vs Dark Cabinets
Dark cabinets are easier to clean as they hide wear and tear better.
Yes, dark cabinets will minimize the space, providing a cozier and more intimate feel.
Buyers typically prefer light cabinets, as they are a more versatile option and can be quickly refreshed with new hardware.
Yes, this can be a great way to add more visual interest. Consider using a dark cabinet for the island and light cabinets for the perimeter, or choosing darker finishes for base cabinets and lighter ones for the uppers.
No, white cabinets remain a popular option. They work well with various kitchen designs, such as Japandi, Scandinavian, and farmhouse.
If you are going for a traditional look, then gold, brass, and bronze are popular choices. Modern cabinetry pairs well with brushed nickel, stainless steel, and chrome.
